ABC News wipes Palestine off the map as US media portray Bethlehem
“It is unconscionable that Bethlehem should be allowed to die slowly from strangulation.”
- Archbishop Desmond Tutu
The Archbishop captures conditions in Bethlehem today as a result of the wall that Israel has built around it, in addition to continued Israeli settlement expansion, travel restrictions on Palestinians and all of the hardships of living under brutal military occupation. As a result, the Christian population is continuing to leave Bethlehem, not due to problems with Muslims, which many in the US media would have us believe, but due to occupation and as Jimmy Carter so aptly labeled, “apartheid” in his new book Palestine: Peace not Apartheid.
According to Open Bethlehem and a Two Nation survey by Zogby International, Americans support Bethlehem – but are not sure where it is.
For full results of the survey visit Open Bethlehem
America vs Bethlehem
Most Americans believe Bethlehem is an Israeli town inhabited by a mixture of Jews and Muslims, a pre-Christmas survey of US perceptions of the town has shown.
Only 15 per cent of Americans realize that it is a Palestinian city with a mixed Christian-Muslim community, lying in the occupied West Bank.
While the Christians of Bethlehem overwhelmingly (78%) blame the exodus of Christians from the town on Israel’s blockade, Americans are more likely (45.9%) to blame it on Islamic politics and are reluctant (7.4%) to blame Israel.
And while four out of ten Americans believe that the wall exists for Israel’s security, more than nine out of ten Bethlehemites believe it is part of a plan by Israel to confiscate Palestinian land.
A sampling of media reports during the Christmas holiday reveal why Americans remain so ignorant of conditions in a town they hold so dear.
ABC News eliminates Palestine from the map:
ABC news provides a good barometer by which to measure the US media’s presentation of Bethlehem as the birthplace of Jesus.
What follows are three clips which reveal why very few Americans know that Israel has constructed a wall around Bethlehem which is strangling the holy city. Only when ABC retraces the steps of the holy family does Wilf Dinnick mention the wall, but at least he does mention the wall and the fact that it cuts off Bethlehem from Jerusalem. Unfortunately, one would get the impression that Palestinians are responsible for this wall being built. There are a few other problems with the presentation, not the least of which is the map.
Imagine if this map was ever presented with the label Palestine instead of Israel.
Contact ABC News
A Festive Bethlehem:
Another ABC report presents a “festive†Bethlehem “where some are wearing santa hatsâ€.
A Subdued Bethlehem
There were no other reports that I saw where the wall was even mentioned. In the interview for the Newshour, it appears that Reverend Jamal Khader is answering a question about the implications of the wall but there is no mention of it. The question and the beginning of the answer were edited out. I’m pretty sure that the “it†to which the priest refers is in fact the wall.
Contact the News Hour at PBS
Finally there is CBS
CBS reported that foreigners stayed away despite Israel’s relaxing of restrictions, though they never address why or what restrictions were supposedly relaxed for that matter.
Contact CBS News
Maybe it’s the ghettoization of Bethlehem as described by Mary Ann Weston in the Chicago Tribune
The city of Christ’s birth is now partially surrounded by a wall, much of it 25 or more feet high, an unbroken expanse of solid, gray concrete, a medieval city wall updated with 21st Century cameras and razor wire. The wall snakes through Bethlehem and the nearby countryside, separating farmers from their fields, workers from their jobs and families from their neighbors. …
The wall effectively annexes Israeli West Bank settlements, although they are considered illegal under international law. The settlements are fast-growing Israeli enclaves built on Palestinian land, their close-packed dwellings marching up once-forested hillsides like monochromatic Lego blocks. Bethlehem is surrounded by 27 settlements containing 73,000 people, according to Open Bethlehem, a local advocacy group. The settlements are connected by bypass roads that are off limits to Palestinians.
The wall and other Israeli restrictions on movement have made Christian and Muslim areas of the West Bank such as Bethlehem virtual ghettos
December 26th, 2006 at 7:26 pm
Excellant report. I too was wondering where Palesitne had gone when ABC made mention of crossing from Jordan into Israel. The reporter acknowledged the check points but failed to reveal that the check points belonged to the Israeli occupying force. ABC should be called into account in their false reporting and their slighting of Palestine.
December 27th, 2006 at 10:13 pm
To the producers:
I was a reporter from Israel and the occupied territories from 1979 to 1988 and have traveled to the West Bank twice since the start of the second Intifada in 2000. I know the region well, intimately by comparison with most reporters (I guided reporters from the major networks around the West Bank during Israel’s Lebanon invasion of 1982 and my Village Voice essay on West Bank reactions to that invasion was cited by Columbia Journalism Review as the only such in the entire American press.) So I think I am well qualified to say the following: your reporter’s ignorance or wilful misrepresentation of fact in this report is simply stupefying. The journey from Bethlehem to Jordan and vice versa is not a journey from “Israel” to Jordan, but from the occupied West Bank to Jordan (viz UN Resolution 242 and Fourth Geneva Convention of 1949 among other bodies of internal law.) The reason for the Israeli military presence - one your reporter mentions as a nuisance for ABC’s travels, but which appears wholly mysterious if the region is Israel (how come all those pesky Arabs living there?) - is to maintain Israel’s stranglehold over the region for the expansion of its settlements. Israel has relentlessly forwarded its illegal settlement-building from 1967 by confiscating the Palestinians’ land and water and by exerting a draconian military code to suppress any Palestinian reaction or resistance. This land-grabbing and the oppression that forwards it, with US government collusion (Americans pay at least $5 billion annually for aid to Israel including the military hardware that destroyed a third of Lebanon and continues destroying Gaza) is the heart of the “hostility” your reporter mentions. (Of course, as per ad nauseam usual he dates such “hostility” back so many millenia that the audience helplessly shrugs and chalks the whole business up to ungovernable, eternal ethnic rivalry.) There is also the segregation wall which one sees clearly on your map of what you allege to be “Israel,” surrounding Bethlehem: it was ruled illegal by the International Court several years ago.
That your reporter mentioned none of this maintains your audience in the state of colossal ignorance which uniquely characterises Americans when it comes to their knowledge of much of anything beyond game show and Hollywood factoids, and massively characterises what they know about the Middle East which in my experience is less than nothing. To know nothing would be preferable to the disinformation clogging the American mind and leaving it to believe that black is white and white, black: the settlements are merely “Jewish neighborhoods,” the occupied territories aren’t “occupied,” but “disputed” (thus Israel’s semantic contortions nullify the facts of international law) that Palestinians occupy Israel, not vice-versa, that the West Bank is “Israel,” that Bethlehem is an Israeli city, etc. This staggering array of stupidities is fostered by the US media. It is lamentable that ABC’s report the other night recapitulates the usual propaganda.
ELLEN CANTAROW
December 28th, 2006 at 9:13 am
[…] Click here to view the ABC report […]